Were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay help

They include air defence assets, maritime patrol capability and infantry forces. There are also regular naval deployments to the region and temporary deployments for routine exercises. The exact force levels are kept under constant review and are structured and maintained at a level consistent with this policy. Mount Pleasant Aerodrome manual Pre deployment information All Service personnel deploying to the Falklands are to do so in accordance with the Joint Individual Mounting Instruction.

Were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay help

Print this page The generals Douglas Haig was 'brilliant to the top of his Army boots'.

"The British Army were Lions led by Donkeys." Discuss. - GCSE History - Marked by initiativeblog.com

They were, supposedly, 'donkeys': Many popular books, films and television programmes echo this belief. The casualty list - one million British Empire dead - and the bloody stalemate of the Western Front seem to add credence to this version of events.

were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay help

But there is another interpretation. Haig's army played the leading role in defeating the German forces in the crucial battles of Moreover, Haig's army played the leading role in defeating the German forces in the crucial battles of In terms of the numbers of German divisions engaged, the numbers of prisoners and guns captured, the importance of the stakes and the toughness of the enemy, the 'Hundred Days' campaign rates as the greatest series of victories in British history.

Even the Somme and Passchendaelebattles that have become by-words for murderous futility, not only had sensible strategic rationales but qualified as British strategic successes, not least in the amount of attritional damage they inflicted on the Germans.

No one denies that the British Expeditionary Force BEF had a bloody learning curve, or that generals made mistakes that had catastrophic consequences. However, before dismissing the generals as mere incompetent buffoons, we must establish the context.

Beforethe British army had been primarily a colonial police force, small but efficient. By it had expanded enormously, taking in a mass of inexperienced civilian volunteers. Later still, it relied on conscripts.

Either way, it was a citizen army rather than a professional force. The generals, used to handling small-scale forces in colonial warfare, had just as much to learn about a type of war for which they were almost entirely unprepared. It is not surprising that in the course of its apprenticeship the BEF had a number of bloody setbacks.

What was extraordinary was that, despite this unpromising beginning, by this army of bank clerks and shop assistants, businessmen and miners should have emerged as a formidable fighting force. Sitting back and letting Britain's principal ally's army be mauled was simply not an option for Haig.

Operation Imposing Law - Wikipedia

An inescapable fact of life for Haig and his predecessor as commander-in-chief, Sir John French, was that Britain was the junior partner in a coalition with France. Naturally, the French tended to call the shots, even though the British C-in-C was an independent commander.

Thus in July Haig fought on the Somme largely at the behest of the French, although he would have preferred to attack, somewhat later, in the Ypres salient where there were more important strategic objectives. At this time the French army was under heavy pressure from German attacks at Verdun.Before the Mutiny, according to Holmes, there had been some 45, British soldiers to about , Indian troops, a ratio of about one to five.

On this page

A royal commission recommended a safety ratio of one to two, the fulfillment of which the British came closest to in the . General Haig, a strong believer in attrition, was the culprit in many people's views including a German commander who praised the British soldiers and described them as 'lions led by donkeys' also criticizing their leaders.

1 Lions Led By Donkeys?


This is an article by Professor Peter Simkin, challenging the idea that Great War generals were incompetent. 2 Lions Led By Donkeys? This is a similar article to the one above and is by Dr Gary Sheffield, another leading WW1 historian. My conclusion British Lions, dutiful British subjects, brilliant and brave young college boys, tough miners, simple honest tradesmen and factory workers were .

"The Battle of the Somme has an enduring legacy, the image of 'lions led by donkeys' established by Alan Clarke; of brave British soldiers sent to their deaths by incompetent generals. But as Christopher Duffy reveals in this groundbreaking study, this was never the Germany view; indeed, the Germans had great respect for the British forces.

No battle in British history is better known than the Battle of the Somme. This case study examines whether the original sources from the time support the view .

Battle of Isandlwana | Military Wiki | FANDOM powered by Wikia